“ The restaurant was very nicely decorated. The staff was very friendly. The live music was excellent. Ben the guitar player was great. He plays for the audience that was in the room. The food was excellent. My companion had the pork. Could not stop saying how tender it was. I will definitely go there again ”

“ Great Place to dine Wonferful staff and awesome food, everything is fresh and taste delightful, Martha the hostess was awesome very catering and wonderful personality. Great place for family, friends, and or an event. I would definitely come again. Me and my wife absolutely enjoyed this place. Our waiter was very friendly food came right out. Very pleasant and peaceful experience. ”

“ This place is simply fantastic and very accommodating! My Grandparents celebrated their 60th Anniversary party here and it was superb beyond words. Gene the very owner was extremely accommodating to our party of around 90 guests. Everything went smoothly, exceeding our expectations beyond words. The food at The Olde Stone Mill was simply exquisite. The staff was extremely knowledgeable answering any questions we had too, which made the experience a very memorable one for us all. I would highly recommend this beautiful establishment to anyone looking for a very fine night of delicious dining with family and friends or to hold an larger event as well. You definitely won't be disappointed in the least bit! ”

“ Had a family function here. My first time dining experience there. I cannot speak highly enough of the SERVICE & FOOD. We were a hungry group of 30. Celebrating a 50 year (Golden) Anniversary. THE WAIT STAFF WAS FRIENDLY, PATIENT & TOLERANT of our senior citizen group. The food was most DELICIOUS. In preparation of this celebration, we were given a choice of 4 entrees in hope to satisfy a little bit for everyone. I had the steak. OMG!! This was cooked to perfection, tender & juicy. EVERYONE was raving about their dish. At the end, we were all well fed, so satisfied with the service, my siblings & I tipped the staff extra. It was well deserved to them all. I highly recommend this restaurant for a simple meal or a larger group in their party room. I wish I live near by to return frequently. ”

“ I truly love this restaurant juicy fresh steaks, nice wine list and very lively inside. You will always have a few guest that are never satisfied, it's not the restaurants fault your bitter and cheap, Haters and low reviews are from local businesses that are now feeling the pressure from the olde stone mill or from customers that think the world has to revolve around them, you know who you are. Keep up the great service good food.Olde Stone Mill Steak House ”

“ Excellent service from "soup to nuts"! From the moment we arrived at the Olde Stone Mill in Tuckahoe around 6:30pm on a Saturday evening, we were greeted by a friendly valet who opened our doors and promptly parked our car. Upon entering the restaurant, we were then greeted by a pleasant hostess who checked our coats and led us into the cozy bar area where we were served a glass of wine by a friendly bartender while waiting for the rest of our party to join us for a 7pm reservation. We were a party of 8 whose request for a round table by the window was granted. Several members of our party did not arrive until 7:30pm, but we were never made to feel rushed. We enjoyed delicious appetizers and were served our entrees by friendly and polite waiters in a timely fashion. By dessert time, I had gotten up to look for the ladies room and was intercepted by the hostess who pointed out the location. In our brief conversation, I had mentioned that we were there to celebrate my birthday, so in the time before I made it back to the table, she had arranged for a piece of red velvet cake to be delivered to the table with a candle and everyone singing 'happy birthday!' After dinner, we made our way back into the cozy bar area where we enjoyed after dinner drinks and some of our favorite songs played on the jukebox. We were having such a nice evening that we were actually the last patrons to leave at 11pm! We would highly recommend this place to anyone who is looking for a very pretty atmosphere, delicious food, decent prices and excellent service with a smile! We will definitely return! ”

“ First time there in about 15 years. I met a friend for brunch last Sunday and was very pleased. The brunch menu was plentiful, not crazy expensive and we enjoyed three choices and they tasted great. The room we were in was beautiful-- glass enclosed area that was warm and bright. I would definitely go back and try them for dinner. ”

“ Thank you, thank you, thank you. Had a Communion Party here and was nervous Bc I'm used to setting up everything myself. I'm a bit meticulous and picked here because of the outdoor patio, on top of the food and service. I was told to leave everything the night before and all would be taken care of...to my complete surprise, I walked into a beautifully, completely set up room right off of Pinterest! Food was amazing, service was amazing and always pleasant, Stephanie, George- THANK YOU, the barmaid has the biggest, friendliest smile, and was amazing to all my guests. I can't thank everyone there from the front, to the back, to the parking attendants for a completely perfect day. My daughter left smiling and happy, and my guests are still speaking about what an amazing time they had. ”